
New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago Schools Weigh Google Search Alternatives Over Gemini AI Policy
Schools in New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago are considering alternatives to Google Search after Google said it would disable Search for schools that opt out of its AI features, according to The New York Times, as cited by The Verge. Starting next year, schools will no longer be able to disable Gemini-powered features while keeping Search enabled. That change puts two decisions together: whether to use the Gemini-powered features and whether to retain Google Search. The three school systems are reported to be considering alternatives, not to have decided to switch. The available excerpt does not name any alternatives, identify which Gemini-powered features are covered, or provide a more precise start date.
Key Takeaways
- New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago schools are considering alternatives to Google Search, according to The New York Times, as cited by The Verge.
- Google said it will disable Search for schools that opt out of its AI features.
- Starting next year, schools will no longer be able to turn off Gemini-powered features while keeping Google Search enabled.
- The excerpt reports that schools are considering alternatives. It does not name those alternatives or say that any of the school systems has decided to switch.
In-Depth Analysis
Opting out of Gemini-powered features will also disable Search
The central change is not simply that Google Search has Gemini-powered features. It is that schools will no longer be able to turn those features off and keep Search enabled. Under the policy described in the report, a school that opts out of the AI features will also lose access to Search. That distinction matters because choosing whether to enable an AI feature is a narrower decision than choosing whether to keep using the search service that includes it. Google’s stated policy makes the two decisions inseparable for schools that want to opt out. The excerpt describes the consequence of that choice but does not list the individual Gemini-powered features at issue. It also does not say that Google Search will be disabled for all schools: the reported condition is that a school opts out of the AI features.
Considering an alternative is not the same as choosing one
The report identifies schools in New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago as considering alternatives in response to Google’s announcement. Their reported response is worth distinguishing from a decision to leave Google Search. Exploring another service is consistent with wanting to understand what an opt-out would mean, but the excerpt does not document an individual district’s reasoning beyond linking the consideration of alternatives to Google’s policy. It also does not say that the three school systems are acting together, evaluating the same services, or following the same timetable. What the report establishes is that alternatives are under consideration in each of the three cities. It does not identify a preferred replacement, a transition plan, or a final decision. The headline’s reference to districts considering dropping Google Search should be read in that limited sense.
The report sets a general timeline, not an exact date
The Verge item is dated November 18, 2026, and describes the change as starting next year, placing the reported start in 2027. The excerpt does not specify a month or day. The timing matters because the report describes schools considering alternatives ahead of a stated change in their options, rather than saying that Google has already disabled Search for them. It also gives a timeline for Google’s policy, not for any school system’s decision. Nothing in the excerpt establishes when New York, Los Angeles, or Chicago schools might decide whether to stay with Google Search, opt out, or choose an alternative. Likewise, the report’s statement about what will happen when schools opt out does not establish that any of the three has already done so.
Industry Impact
The significance for the AI industry is in how Google ties an AI setting to access to an existing service. As described in the report, the decision facing a school is not only whether it wants Gemini-powered features. It is also whether it wants to keep Google Search under terms that no longer let it disable those features separately. The reported response from schools in three cities gives a concrete example of how an AI product policy can prompt institutions to consider alternatives to the underlying service, even when the immediate issue is whether they can turn off its AI features.
That is a narrower finding than a shift away from Google Search across education. The excerpt shows that alternatives are being considered, but it does not show that a competing service has gained users or even that a particular service is under review. It also offers no basis for determining how common this response is beyond the three school systems named. The industry implication is therefore limited but clear: when a provider makes AI features a condition of keeping a service enabled, an institution’s decision about those features can become a decision about the service itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can schools turn off Gemini-powered features and keep Google Search?
Not under the policy described in the report. Starting next year, schools that opt out of the Gemini-powered features will also have Google Search disabled. The excerpt does not describe any exceptions or specify the individual features covered.
Have New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago schools decided to leave Google Search?
The report says they are considering alternatives. It does not say any of the three school systems has made a final decision, selected a replacement, or set a date for switching.
When will Google’s school Search policy change?
The November 2026 report says the change will start next year, meaning 2027. The excerpt does not give a more specific start date or say when the school systems might decide how to respond.


